The Gourmet Whaler Menu

If you're looking for a memorable dining experience, the The Gourmet Whaler Menu offers something special. Nestled at 111 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, this cozy spot combines fresh, locally sourced ingredients with a unique twist on classic dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty seafood entrée or a lighter bite, each dish is crafted with care and designed to satisfy every palate.

Start off with their signature appetizers, bursting with flavors, before diving into the main courses that showcase the finest catches of the season. From tender cuts of meat to expertly prepared fish, each dish is balanced with fresh herbs and innovative sauces. Don’t forget to leave room for dessert, as the sweet creations here are the perfect way to round out your meal.

It’s more than just food; it’s an experience. The menu brings together comfort and creativity, making it easy to find something you’ll love, no matter the occasion. So, whether you're here for a casual dinner or a celebration, there's no shortage of delicious options to explore.

Ice cream

Extra Large Ice Cream
US$8.76
Large Ice Cream
US$6.95
Ice Cream Toppings
US$1.03
Medium Ice Cream
US$5.92
Small Ice Cream
US$4.89
Sugar Cone
US$0.77
Waffle Cone
US$1.55

Bakery

Banana Bread
US$5.67
Brownie
US$4.89
Chocolate Chip Cookie
US$3.71
Crumb Cake Slice
US$4.11
Croissant
US$3.86
Cupcake
US$3.71
Gluten Free Muffin
US$5.14
Happy Cookie
US$3.35
Muffin
US$4.64
Power Bites
US$2.58
Raspberry Square
US$4.89
Scone
US$4.64
Brownie Milkshake Sandwich
US$7.71
Coconut Macaroons
US$4.11
Lemon Bar
US$5.14
Malted Milk Blondie
US$5.14
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
US$3.35
Peanut Butter Brownie Bar
US$5.14
Smores Bar
US$6.17
SnoBall
US$6.70
Tres Leches Cups
US$8.23
Whoopie Pie
US$5.14
Cake Pop
US$4.11
Cosmic Cookie
US$7.21
Giant Oreo Cookie
US$6.70
Giant Walnut Cookie
US$6.70
Key Lime Pie Bar
US$8.23
Nutella Cheese Cake Cups
US$7.20
Matcha Cookie
US$6.70
Smores Cookie
US$3.61
Nutella Stuffed Cookie
US$6.70
Biscuit
US$3.61
Gluten Free Biscuit
US$4.64
Sesame Scallion Biscuit
US$4.64
Banana Pudding Cookie
US$6.70
Blueberry Pie Bar
US$6.18
Carrot Cake Slice
US$8.23
Coconut Bar
US$5.14
Coconut Cake Slice
US$8.23
Coffee Toffee
US$6.70
Cruffin
US$4.89
Fruity Pebble Cookie
US$3.61
Giant Cookie Butter Cookie
US$6.70
Gluten Free Brownie
US$4.89
Mini Pies
US$17.00
Oatmeal Crème Pie
US$5.67
Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookie
US$6.70
Poptart
US$4.64
Pumpkin Bread
US$5.15
Stuffed Dates
Your Choice Of Almond Or Peanut Butter Stuffed Dates Dipped In Vegan Chocolate
US$6.18
Twinkie
US$4.11
Everything Biscuit
US$4.12
Almond Joy Bar
US$6.64
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie
US$3.61

Cold Drinks

Cucumber Lemonade
US$8.23
Fresh Fruit Lemonades
US$8.23
Large Iced Tea
US$4.89
Medium Iced Tea
US$4.11
Small Iced Tea
US$3.35
Lavender Lemonade
US$5.67
Fizzes
Think Dirty Soda!
US$5.67

Coffee & Tea

Large Hot Coffee
US$4.48
Large Cold Brew
US$7.16
Medium Cold Brew
24 Oz
US$6.13
Small Hot Coffee
US$3.09
Small Cold Brew
US$5.10
Medium Hot Coffee
16 Oz
US$3.61
Small Iced Coffee
US$4.12
Large Iced Coffee
US$6.18
Medium Iced Coffee
US$5.15
Large Cappuccino
US$6.18
Large Hot Tea (2 Bags)
US$4.64
Medium Hot Tea
US$3.61
Small Hot Tea
US$3.09
Add Extra Shot
US$1.80
Large Cold Drink
US$4.89
Medium Cold Drink
24 Oz
US$4.11
Small Cold Drink
US$3.35
Flavored Syrup
US$1.03

Specialty Lattes & Drinks

Matcha Latte
US$6.17
Small Latte (16oz)
US$5.67
Chai Latte
US$5.67
Large Latte (24oz)
US$6.70
Matcha Lemonade (16oz)
US$8.23
Matcha Lemonade (24oz)
US$8.76
Smores Hot Chocolate
US$7.73
Large Matcha Tea (Water Only)
US$5.41
Fizzes
Think Dirty Soda!
US$5.67
Large Matcha Latte
US$7.21
Add Extra Shot
US$1.80
Espresso
US$3.86
Cappuccino
US$5.15
16oz Fresh OJ Juice
US$12.36
Greek Frappe
US$5.67
Small Hot Chocolate
US$5.15
Americano
Double Shot Of Espresso With 6oz Hot Water
US$4.64
Cappuccino Freddo
US$5.67
Flavored Syrup
US$1.03

Prepped Food

Ham And Swiss Croisssant
Ham, Swiss Cheese & Honey Mustard on our homemade Croissants topped with Poppy Seeds
US$12.31
Roasted Pepper Croissant
Roasted Peppers, Pesto, Balsmaic & Mozzarella Cheese on one of our Homemade Croissants Topped With Sesame Seeds.
US$10.25
Turkey Cheddar Croissant
Turkey, Cheddar Chesse & Chipotle Mayo on Our Homemade Croissant topped with Sesame & Poppy Seeds
US$12.31
Breakfast Quesadilla
Sausage, Egg And Cheese
US$6.70
Buffalo Pretzel Bomb
Chicken, Cheese, And Buffalo Sauce In A Homemade Pretzel
US$5.15
Pepperoni Pizza Pretzel Bomb
Pepperoni, Pizza Sauce, And Mozzarella In A Homemade Pretzel
US$5.15
Mac And Cheese Cups
US$6.17
1/2 Lb Bird In Hand Chicken Salad
US$9.79
Pre-Made Salad
Salad Of Your Choice - This Option May Be Unavailable, Please Call 631-659-2977 To Confirm!
US$12.31

Fridge Items

Coconut Water
US$5.15
Large Topo Chico
US$6.18
Mexican Soda
US$4.38
Poland Spring
US$2.06
Stuffed Dates
Your Choice Of Almond Or Peanut Butter Stuffed Dates Dipped In Vegan Chocolate
US$6.18
Topo Chico
US$3.61
Nesquik
US$3.61
Milk
US$3.09
Poppi
US$3.61
Celsius
US$4.12
Bloom
US$5.15
Tropicana OJ
US$3.61
Martinelli's Apple Juice
US$4.12
Large Essentia Water
US$6.18
Diet Coke Can
US$2.58

Kids Lunch

Grilled Cheese
Oooey Gooey American Cheese on our Signature White Bread
US$9.22
Kids Chicken Tenders
US$10.25
Cheese Quesadilla
Monterey Jack in a Flour Tortilla with a side of Gucamole & Sour Cream
US$13.34
Hot Dog
Served In A Potato Hot Dog Bun
US$5.67

Extras

Side Of Buttered Toast
2 Slices Of Your Choice Of Toast
US$2.58
Side Of Bacon
4 Strips Of Bacon
US$5.15
Side Of Sausage
2 Pieces Of Sausage
US$4.64
Side Of Ham
3 Pieces Of Ham
US$4.64
Side Of Avocado
US$3.61
Side Of Guacamole
US$4.64
1 Slice Of Toast (For Salads)
US$1.55
Side Of Turkey Bacon
US$5.15
Side Of Coleslaw
US$3.09
Side Of Grilled Chicken
US$5.67
Side Of Mango Salsa
US$3.09
Side Of Home Fries
US$5.67
Dressing On The Side
US$1.03

Shareables

Chicken Tenders
US$14.37
Fried Clams
Served with Tartar Sauce & Coleslaw
US$14.37
Crazy Tots
Tater Tots topped with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon & Ranch
US$9.79
Tots
US$4.89
French Fries
US$4.89
Sweet Potato Fries
US$4.89

Burgers

The Whaler Burger
6 oz Burger with Lettuce, Tomato & Onion on a Brioche Bun
US$15.40
The Veggie Burger
Veggie Burger topped with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion on a Brioche Bun
US$15.40

Tacos & Quesadillas

"Famous" Fish Tacos
Panko- Breaded fried Flounder with Signature Slaw& Chipotle Mayo. Side of Peach Mango Salsa
US$15.40
Shrimp Tacos
Grilled Shrimp topped with Avocado, Corn Salsa, Iceberg Lettuce & Chipotle Mayo
US$15.40
Chicken Quesadilla
Monterey Jack Cheese, Grilled Chicken & Pico De Gallo in a Flour Tortilla. Served with Gucamole & Sour Cream on Side
US$16.43
Baja Style Tacos
Pan- Seared Mahi Mahi topped with Shredded Red& Green Cabbage, Avocado, Pico De Gallo & Cilantro Lime Crema
US$15.40
Veggie Tacos
A Mix of Roasted Corn, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Squash & Peppers. Topped with Iceberg Lettuce, Avocado, Pico De Gallo, Queso Fresco & Chipotle Mayo
US$15.40

Salads

Cobb Salad
Romaine with Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Avocado, Tomatoes & Blue Cheese Crumbles with Ranch Dressing
US$17.46
Greek Salad
Romaine Lettuce with Peppers, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, Cucumbers Tomatoes & Feta Cheese served with Greek Dressing
US$14.37
Caesar Salad
Romaine tossed with Parmesan Cheese, Croutons & Caesar Dressing
US$14.37
Quinoa Bowl
Warm Quinoa sautéed with Garlic, Onions, Mushrooms & Corn. Topped with Avocado, Tomato, Cucumber and Lettuce. Served with Lime and Chipotle Mayo on Side
US$15.40
Bird In Hand Salad
White Meat Chicekn blended with Apples, Cranberries, Walnuts, & a touch of Mayo. Served Over Greens or a Wrap with Raspberry Mayo
US$15.40
Cobb Salad Wrap
Grilled Chicken with Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Blue Cheese Crumbles & Ranch Dressing
US$16.43
Soup Of The Day
Call To Ask!
US$10.29

Wraps

Grilled Chicken Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Chipotle Mayo
US$15.40
California Wrap
Turkey With Avocado, Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Ranch Dressing
US$15.40
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken Cutlet with Homemade Buffalo Sauce Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Blue Cheese Dressing.
US$16.43
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken with Parmesan, Lettuce, Croutons, & Caesar Dressing
US$15.40

Sandwiches (Lunch)

Super Grilled Cheese
Swiss and American Cheese with Bacon, Tomato & Avocado
US$15.40
Classic BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo
US$13.34
Cuban Hero
Roast Pork with BBQ Sauce on a Brioche Bun. Served with a Side of Slaw
US$15.40
Pulled Pork Sandwhich
Pulled Pork with BBQ Sauce on a Brioche Bun. Served with a Side of Slaw
US$14.37
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo on a Brioche Bun
US$13.34
Turkey Club
Sliced Turkey Breast with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo Served On 3 Slices Of White Toast
US$16.43
Philly Cheesesteak
Steak with Peppers, Onions, Garlic & Mozzarella Cheese on a Hero
US$15.40
Soup Of The Day
Call To Ask!
US$10.29

UNCATEGORIZED

Add Extra Egg
US$2.06
Add Onion
US$1.03
Add Turkey
US$4.64
Fresh Fruit Cup
US$6.18
Sub Breaded Chicken
US$1.03
Cup Of Ice
US$1.03
Add Breaded Chiclen
US$6.70
Add Grilled Chicken
US$5.67
Add Guacamole
US$4.64
Banana
US$1.03
Hal's Large Chips
US$5.15
Add Avocado
US$3.09
Add Tomato
US$1.03
Hal's Small Chips
US$2.83
Lemon Slice
US$0.26
Add Cheese
US$2.06
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 631-659-2977